What Are Borrowed Chords in Music, and How Do iv, ♭VI and ♭VII Work in C Major?

Borrowed Chords: Using Modal Mixture in Major and Minor Keys

A major-key progression does not have to use only chords derived from the major scale. Composers can introduce harmonies from the parallel minor, creating a different emotional colour while keeping the same tonic.

This technique is called modal mixture, or mode mixture. The chords themselves are often described as borrowed chords.

Borrowed chords are among the most accessible ways to introduce chromatic harmony. They can make a familiar progression sound darker, more ambiguous, more dramatic or simply more varied without requiring a full modulation.

1. What Are Borrowed Chords?

A borrowed chord is a chord taken from the parallel mode of the current key.

The parallel major and minor keys share the same tonic but use different scale structures.

For example:

• C major is the major mode with C as its tonic.
• C minor is the minor mode with C as its tonic.

The two scales differ in several notes:

C major: C–D–E–F–G–A–B

C natural minor: C–D–E-flat–F–G–A-flat–B-flat

A composer writing in C major can borrow chords from C minor. These chords introduce notes such as E-flat, A-flat and B-flat, which are not part of the C major scale.

The music can still remain centred on C.

That is the essential idea behind modal mixture.

2. Common Borrowed Chords in C Major

Several chords from C minor are frequently used in C major.

The exact interpretation of a borrowed chord depends on its harmonic context. The Roman numerals shown here describe its relationship to the C major tonic.

The most familiar examples include iv, ♭VI and ♭VII.

3. The Minor Subdominant: iv in a Major Key

One of the most characteristic borrowed chords is the minor subdominant.

In C major, the ordinary subdominant is F major:

F – A – C

Borrowing from C minor changes it to F minor:

F – A-flat – C

The A-flat introduces a chromatic note that changes the character of the harmony.

A particularly familiar progression is:

F minor → C major

In Roman numerals:

iv → I

The minor subdominant can create a bittersweet or reflective colour before returning to the major tonic.

This movement is common in classical, Romantic, jazz and popular music.

The expressive effect depends on the context. It can sound nostalgic, dramatic, intimate or understated.

4. The Flat Sixth Chord: ♭VI

Another frequently used borrowed chord is the major chord built on the lowered sixth scale degree.

In C major, this is A-flat major:

A-flat – C – E-flat

The chord introduces two notes from C minor: A-flat and E-flat.

It can create a strong contrast with the surrounding diatonic harmony.

One possible progression is:

C – A-flat – F – G – C

The A-flat chord provides a sudden shift in harmonic colour while the music retains C as its tonal reference.

The ♭VI chord can also participate in more complex progressions, including movements towards the dominant.

5. The Flat Seventh Chord: ♭VII

The flat seventh chord in C major is B-flat major:

B-flat – D – F

It is commonly associated with the Mixolydian mode, although it also appears as a borrowed chord in major-key progressions.

A familiar progression is:

C – B-flat – F – C

The movement has a strong modal character and is common in rock, pop and film music.

Unlike a conventional dominant chord, B-flat major does not contain the leading tone B natural. Its relationship to C is therefore different from that of G major or G7.

The result can sound more open and less strongly directed towards a traditional dominant-to-tonic cadence.

6. Borrowed Chords in Minor Keys

Modal mixture also works in the opposite direction.

A composition in C minor can borrow chords from C major.

For example, F major may appear instead of F minor, or A major may be used in a context where the natural-minor scale would suggest A-flat minor.

In practice, minor-key harmony already draws on more than one form of the minor scale.

Composers commonly use natural, harmonic and melodic minor forms, especially when creating dominant harmony.

It is therefore important to distinguish between ordinary variations of minor-key practice and a deliberate borrowed chord from the parallel major.

The harmonic context determines how the chord is understood.

7. Borrowed Chords and Voice Leading

The chromatic notes in borrowed chords can create expressive voice-leading opportunities.

Consider F minor resolving to C major:

F minor: F–A-flat–C

C major: C–E–G

One particularly effective movement is:

A-flat → G

The lowered sixth scale degree moves down by semitone to the fifth of the tonic chord.

Other voices can move to C and E.

This creates a smooth connection between the borrowed chord and the tonic.

The emotional character of the progression comes partly from the contrast between the minor subdominant and the major tonic, but also from the movement of the individual notes.

8. Modal Mixture in Modern Music

Borrowed chords are extremely common in modern musical styles.

In pop and rock, ♭VII and iv can provide contrast without introducing a conventional modulation.

In film scoring, ♭VI and minor-subdominant harmony can create dramatic or reflective colours.

In jazz, modal mixture expands the range of available chord substitutions and harmonic colours.

In ambient music, borrowed chords can be used sparingly to transform the atmosphere of a slowly evolving progression.

A single A-flat major chord in an otherwise diatonic C major environment may be enough to change the perceived emotional character of an entire passage.

9. Borrowed Chords in Generative Composition

Modal mixture can also be incorporated into generative systems.

Instead of selecting every chord from one scale, a system can use two related pitch collections:

• The current major scale
• The parallel minor scale

A probability rule can determine when borrowed chords become available.

For example:

• Use diatonic chords for most harmonic events.
• Allow iv or ♭VI at selected structural points.
• Prefer a return to I after a borrowed minor-subdominant chord.
• Use ♭VII when a more modal or rock-oriented character is desired.

This creates a system that remains recognisably centred on one tonic while allowing controlled changes of harmonic colour.

10. Practical Exercise

Begin with this progression in C major:

C – F – G7 – C

Create three variations:

1. Replace F major with F minor.
2. Insert A-flat major before F major.
3. Use B-flat major in place of G major to create a more modal progression.

Then experiment with the following:

F minor – C major

A-flat major – F major – G7 – C

C – B-flat – F – C

Compare the different harmonic characters.

Notice that you can introduce considerable chromatic colour without necessarily leaving C as the tonal centre.

Conclusion

Borrowed chords allow composers to draw on the parallel major and minor modes while retaining the same tonic.

They are a particularly effective way to expand harmonic colour without requiring a complete modulation.

The minor subdominant, flat sixth and flat seventh chords are especially useful because they introduce distinctive chromatic relationships while remaining relatively easy to integrate into familiar progressions.

For electronic composers, modal mixture offers a practical way to make a diatonic sequence more expressive without making its harmonic structure unnecessarily complicated.

Just click here to dive deeper into the topic.