My Musical Dialogues With ChatGPT - Part 2 "Modular Synthesis"

Me:

After being nearly forgotten by the public modular synthesis has seen a great comeback in the last, let´s say 10 years. What are the reasons for that?

 

ChatGPT:

There are several reasons for the resurgence of modular synthesis in recent years:

1. Versatility: Modular synthesis offers a high degree of versatility, allowing users to create a wide range of sounds and music. This versatility has made modular synthesis a popular choice among musicians, producers, and sound designers.

2. Experimentation: Modular synthesis provides an open-ended platform for experimentation and exploration, encouraging musicians to push the boundaries of what is possible in sound and music production.

3. Flexibility: The modular design of synthesis systems allows users to build and reconfigure their setups as they see fit, providing a level of flexibility that is difficult to achieve with traditional synthesis methods.

4. Sound quality: Many modular synthesizers are built with high-quality components, resulting in a superior sound quality that is not always achievable with digital synthesis methods.

5. Nostalgia: Modular synthesis has a long history, stretching back to the 1950s, and has been associated with many influential musicians and sound designers. This nostalgia has helped to fuel the resurgence of interest in modular synthesis in recent years.

In conclusion, the resurgence of modular synthesis can be attributed to a combination of its versatility, experimentation potential, flexibility, sound quality, and nostalgia.

 

Me:

Alright then. But all of that – perhaps but for the aspect of nostalgia – was vallid in the 1990s too, as well as in the early years of the 21st century. Why has this hype occurred of all things in the last few recent years?

 

ChatGPT:

There are several reasons for the recent resurgence in popularity of modular synthesis:

1. Technological advancements: Recent advancements in technology have made modular synthesis more accessible and affordable for a wider range of people. This has allowed more people to experience the joys of modular synthesis and has opened up new possibilities for creative expression.

2. Increased interest in electronic music: With the growth of electronic music as a genre, more people have become interested in the tools and techniques used to produce electronic music. Modular synthesis is an important part of this, and as more people have become interested in electronic music, more people have also become interested in modular synthesis.

3. The "DIY" culture: The recent rise of the "DIY" culture has also contributed to the resurgence in popularity of modular synthesis. People are increasingly interested in building their own tools and instruments, and modular synthesis is a perfect fit for this type of experimentation and creativity.

4. Nostalgia: Some people have a nostalgic attachment to modular synthesis, and have rediscovered the joys of modular synthesis after many years of not using it. This has helped to drive renewed interest in modular synthesis.

In conclusion, the recent resurgence in popularity of modular synthesis can be attributed to a combination of technological advancements, increased interest in electronic music, the "DIY" culture, and nostalgia.

 

Me:

Can´t the musical impotence of popular music of the last decade be a reason as well?

 

ChatGPT:

Yes, the musical inadequacy of popular music in recent years could be one of the reasons for the resurgence of modular synthesis. As people become tired of the limited and formulaic nature of much of popular music, they may be seeking out new and more creative forms of musical expression. Modular synthesis, with its open-ended and non-linear approach to sound design, provides a means of exploring new sonic territories and creating highly personalized and expressive music. Additionally, the availability of affordable and user-friendly modular systems has made this form of synthesis accessible to a wider range of musicians and producers, further fueling its resurgence in popularity.

 

Me:

Let´s talk about the aspect of versatility that you mentioned. Don´t you think the indeed immense versatility that modular synthesis offers may be rather daunting than motivating for a hobby musician as well as for a professional sound designer. There are legions of synthesizers out there, which are easier to work with, and which offer a huge amount of different sounds and sound tweaking functions nevertheless.

 

ChatGPT:

Yes, the versatility of modular synthesis can be intimidating, especially for those who are not familiar with synthesis and sound design. However, the learning curve can be steep, but once you get the hang of it, you'll find that the possibilities are virtually endless. Additionally, many people enjoy the hands-on, tactile aspect of working with modular synthesizers, as well as the ability to create truly unique and personalized sounds. It's not for everyone, but for those who enjoy the challenge and the creativity that it provides, it can be a rewarding experience. Additionally, many modular synthesizers now come with software tools and tutorials to make the learning process easier. So, while modular synthesis may not be the best choice for everyone, it's definitely worth considering if you're interested in exploring new sonic territory and pushing the boundaries of what's possible in sound design and music production.

 

Me:

Let me accept this – at least for the moment – and throw a spotlight to another aspect. Does it still make any sense to spend a lot of money and buy huge numbers of modules, when – on the other hand – there are great software modular synths like VCV Rack, Cherry Audio´s Voltage Modular, Softube´s Modular or synth building blocks like NI´s Reaktor?

 

ChatGPT:

It depends on personal preferences and priorities. For some musicians and sound designers, the physical interaction and tactile experience offered by hardware modular synthesizers is an important factor that can enhance their creative process and performance. On the other hand, software modular synthesizers offer convenience, affordability, and accessibility, as well as the ability to quickly and easily recall and save patches, and to use a computer's processing power for complex sound processing. Both hardware and software modular synthesizers have their own benefits and drawbacks, and the choice between them ultimately comes down to personal preference and specific needs and goals.

 

Me:

Well, and to budgets I imagine!

 

ChatGPT:

Yes, budget is definitely a factor to consider when choosing between hardware and software modular synthesizers. Hardware modular synthesizers can be quite expensive, especially when you start adding multiple modules and building a complex system. On the other hand, software modular synthesizers are often more affordable and offer a wider range of options at different price points. Additionally, with software modular synthesizers, you have the option to try before you buy, with many offering demos or free versions that you can use to get a feel for the software before making a purchase.

 

Me:

Let´s follow these thought a bit further before coming to the other aspects, which you mentioned at the beginning. The matter of adding modules seems kind of crucial to me here. With software modular synths, especially the freeware VCV Rack, it is rather tempting to expand your setup to crazy dimensions. The monetary limitations when buying hardware modules may lead to more focused approaches here. And that can be an advantage, or can´t it?

 

ChatGPT:

Yes, that can definitely be an advantage. When working with hardware modular synths, the monetary limitations can force the user to be more focused and creative in their approach, as they are limited to the number of modules they can purchase. This can lead to a more streamlined and focused modular system, which can in turn lead to more unique and interesting sound design. On the other hand, with software modular synths like VCV Rack, it's easy to add more and more modules, which can lead to a cluttered and overwhelming setup. Having a limited budget can help you focus your setup and make more effective use of the modules you do have, leading to more creative and inspired sound design.

 

Me:

Last question belonging to this, well, line of thoughts: Is digitalisation even in hardware modules a development in the wrong direction? Are modules that need a lot of menu diving, and which are more or less a complete synthesizer in their own, still carrying the spirit of modular?

 

ChatGPT:

Digitalization in hardware modules is not necessarily a development in the wrong direction. It depends on personal preference and the intended use. Modules that require menu diving can still be considered part of the modular spirit if they offer a wide range of capabilities and the ability to connect and interact with other modules in unique and creative ways. However, some people prefer the simplicity and hands-on approach of analog modular systems and feel that digitalization takes away from that. Ultimately, the choice between analog and digital modular systems is a matter of personal preference and intended use.

 

Me:

Well, well. Back to your first statements. Experimentation and pushing boundaries. When I jump in France into the English Channel I have a huge mass of water to cross, but I´m still able to know what I´m aiming for: reaching England. It´s a big task, but the aim is clear. When I´m thrown into the middle of the Pacific Ocean I don´t even know where I am. Isn´t starting with modular synthesis a bit like being thrown into the Pacific Ocean? Without orientation, without an at least vague target to go to?

 

ChatGPT:

Starting with modular synthesis can certainly be intimidating and overwhelming, especially with the vast array of modules and possibilities available. However, having a clear goal or idea in mind can help to focus the experimentation and exploration process. Many modular enthusiasts find it helpful to start with a specific project or musical idea in mind, and then gradually expand their setup as their knowledge and skills develop. Additionally, there are many resources available, such as online forums, tutorials, and workshops, that can provide guidance and support for those starting with modular synthesis. The key is to approach it with an open mind, a willingness to experiment, and a desire to push the boundaries of what is possible with sound.

 

Me:

I see. But even these resources are not easy to evaluate and partly of rather doubtful quality. But well. So, you see having a clear goal or certain project in mind as an important – and perhaps “life saving” - strategy here?

 

ChatGPT:

Yes, having a clear goal or a specific project in mind can be helpful in making the most of modular synthesis. Having a clear direction can help to focus your experimentation and ensure that you are using the resources available to you effectively. It can also help you to make the most of your investment, by ensuring that you are buying modules that are relevant to your needs, and that you are using them in ways that support your overall objectives.

 

Me:

About sound quality now. Why do you think that modular synthesizer systems deliver a better sound quality than desktop synths?

 

ChatGPT:

Modular synthesizer systems are often thought to deliver better sound quality compared to desktop synths due to several factors:

1. Analogue circuitry: Modular synths use analogue circuitry, which can produce warm, organic, and authentic sounds compared to digital circuitry used in desktop synths.

2. Signal routing flexibility: Modular synths offer greater flexibility in terms of signal routing, which can result in unique and complex soundscapes that are hard to achieve with desktop synths.

3. The patching concept: The patching concept of modular synths allows for the creation of unique signal processing chains, which can result in distinctive and dynamic sounds.

4. The use of voltage control: Modular synths use voltage control to manipulate sound parameters, which can result in greater expressiveness and control over sound compared to digital synths, where control is often limited to numerical values.

However, it's important to note that sound quality is subjective and depends on various factors, including the individual's preferences, the specific modules and desktop synths used, and the type of sound being produced.

 

Me:

I see the matter of analogue versus digital shining through your answer. But let´s not talk about this today. And even desktop synths use voltage control. Anyway. Let´s get practical. Let´s imagine a guy, and let´s call him Syd Synthfan. Syd wants to go modular, but doesn´t have any idea how to start. Can you help him?

 

ChatGPT:

Sure! If Syd Synthfan wants to start with modular synthesis, here are a few practical tips that might help:

1. Start small: Don't try to buy all the modules at once. Start with a small setup and then add modules as you go along.

2. Familiarize yourself with basic concepts: Before buying any modules, it's a good idea to understand the basics of voltage control, signal routing, and sound synthesis.

3. Read reviews and watch tutorials: There are many resources available online that can help you get started with modular synthesis. Read reviews, watch tutorials, and find out what other people have to say about the modules you're interested in.

4. Get to know the community: Modular synthesis has a passionate and supportive community, so get involved and ask questions.

5. Experiment: The beauty of modular synthesis is that there are no rules, so don't be afraid to experiment and see what kind of sounds you can create.

6. Plan your system: Before you start buying modules, it's a good idea to plan out your system and think about what kind of sounds you want to create.

7. Start with a power supply and a case: Once you have a basic understanding of modular synthesis, start by buying a power supply and a case. These are the backbone of your system, and you can then add modules as you go along.

8. Get a beginner-friendly module: Consider starting with a module that's easy to use, such as an oscillator, filter, or envelope generator. These modules are a great starting point, and you can use them to create simple patches and experiment with different sound designs.

With these tips, Syd Synthfan should be able to get started with modular synthesis and begin exploring the world of sound design and experimentation!

 

Me:

Last question: What would you answer to someone telling you that modular synthesis is allways only about generating blibs and pieps and blobs?

ChatGPT:

I would say that the statement is not entirely accurate and it is a limited view of what modular synthesis can do. Modular synthesis can create a wide range of sounds, from complex textures and atmospheric sounds to complex melodies and percussive elements. It is true that some modular setups can focus on creating experimental and abstract sounds, but this is just one aspect of its capabilities. With the right modules and a creative approach, modular synthesis can create any sound that you can imagine. It is not limited to just bleeps and bloops.

 

Me:

Thank you for this conversation. Have a good time and enjoy your day!

 

Chat GPT:

You're welcome! Have a great day!

to part 1: https://www.dev.rofilm-media.net/node/532

to part 3: https://www.dev.rofilm-media.net/node/582